Electric toasters are a common household appliance that most of us use daily. However, like any other device, they have a limited lifespan. Knowing when to replace your electric toaster is important, as using an old and faulty toaster can lead to safety hazards and less-than-perfect toast. In this article, we will explore how often an electric toaster should be replaced and what factors you should consider while making the decision.

1 - Heating Elements

The heating elements in an electric toaster are responsible for evenly toasting your bread. Over time, these elements can become worn out or damaged, resulting in uneven toasting and longer toasting times. If you notice that your toaster is taking longer to toast bread or is producing unevenly toasted bread, it may be time to replace it.

2 - Crumb Tray

The crumb tray in an electric toaster catches crumbs and other debris that fall from the bread during toasting. If this tray becomes damaged or difficult to clean, it can pose a fire hazard. If you notice that your crumb tray is damaged or difficult to clean, it may be time to replace your toaster.

3 - Safety Features

Electric toasters come with a variety of safety features, including automatic shut-off and heat-resistant housing. If your toaster is lacking in these features or is showing signs of wear and tear, it may be time to replace it for safety reasons.

4 - Age

Like any other appliance, electric toasters have a limited lifespan. While the average lifespan of an electric toaster can vary depending on the brand and model, most toasters last between 5-10 years. If your toaster is approaching or exceeding this lifespan, it may be time to consider replacing it.

5 - Other Issues

Other issues that may indicate the need for a new toaster include a malfunctioning lever or button, a loose or wobbly base, or a damaged power cord. These issues can not only affect the quality of your toast but can also pose safety hazards.

Tips When Buying a New Toaster

1 - Look for One with Variable Width Slots

Variable width slots allow you to toast a variety of bread sizes and thicknesses, ensuring that your toast comes out perfectly every time.

2 - Consider the Number of Toasting Slots

Think about how many slices of bread you typically toast at once and choose a toaster with the appropriate number of slots. If you have a large family or frequently entertain guests, a toaster with four slots may be more practical.

3 - Check the Toasting Settings

Make sure the toaster has multiple toasting settings, including a setting for bagels if you frequently toast bagels. Some toasters also have a defrost setting for frozen bread.

4 - Look for a Removable Crumb Tray

A removable crumb tray makes cleaning your toaster much easier and helps prevent potential fire hazards caused by accumulated crumbs.

5 - Consider the Design and Style

Toasters come in a variety of designs and styles, so choose one that complements your kitchen décor and personal taste. Some toasters even come in fun colours and patterns, adding a pop of personality to your kitchen.


Knowing when to replace your electric toaster is important for safety reasons and to ensure that you are getting the best quality toast possible. By monitoring the heating elements, crumb tray, safety features, age, and other issues, you can make an informed decision about when it's time to replace your toaster.

If you are looking to get a new Smeg toaster, come and shop at Beales. We have everything you need from homewares, electricals, fashion, footwear, and fragrance to furniture. Come and see what we can offer today!

May 15, 2023 — Paul Masterson